A nice discussion regarding Super Mario Galaxy 2 is going on over at 4cr sister site Phantom Leap. Rumas, like myself, is a huge fan of the original Galaxy and is looking forward to the second installment, but understandably has some questions as to the me-too nature of the game. This little quote by Rumas set off a number of amazing comments over at PL and two follow up posts:

As a tremendous fan, I can’t wait to get my hands on the sequel…but one of Nintendo’s trademarks as respects its core franchises has always been to constantly pioneer in terms of both content and execution, never to tread the same ground twice. Considering what became of Mario 64 2, I’m surprised Miyamoto gave this one the okay.

Very interesting stuff. I’m of two minds on the whole issue. Clearly Galaxy was amazing and more of it is a good thing. In fact, I think with Super Mario Galaxy Nintendo finally figured out how to really really do Mario in a 3D universe. The mechanics in Galaxy feel like the most pure interpretation of classic 2D Mario in a 3D game. And the game is just so full of fun ideas and beauty. So I love the fact that we are getting more of that. But at the same time, I agree with Rumas that it seems like an odd move for Nintendo to do a straight up sequel like this.

But maybe, as is brought up over at PL, this can be read as a deep view into the new Nintendo. The blue ocean, casual game making, broad appeal, world dominating Nintendo of today. Head on over and read the goods and join the conversation and let us know what you think.

Super Mario Galaxy 2 Discussion - Part 1
Super Mario Galaxy 2 Discussion - Part 2
Super Mario Galaxy 2 Discussion - Part 3