by Mitch - 04.02.07

Gather around, children, and I’ll tell you a story about the Great War. Its name was true to its nature - it pitted man against man, red against blue, and blast processing verses brand name. This was the Great War — The Console War.
Hey kids! Put down your DSes and your PSPs - quit swingin’ those Wiis around, and knock it off with your newfangled pixel shading and your whipper-snappin’ bump-mapping. I’m going to tell you kids a story about allegiances back in the days of the console wars. Much like the Allies and the Axis during one of those other unimportant wars, there were two camps: you were either a Nintendo kid or you were most certainly a Sega kid. Back in the days before Sony entered the fray with its PlayStation, it was one or the other — you wore Mario underwear or Sonic underwear, period. And you were pitted against each other constantly!
That is, until the day that Sega turned everything we grew up knowing on its head. What scared me the most wasn’t that my biggest childhood rival was openly fraternizing with my epic hero - it was that I just didn’t care.

Imagine yourself in the dog days of the early 90s. The political climate had just completed yet another revolution before I’d popped out of my mother’s womb and the pitfalls that other companies had fallen into time and time again were leaped over in effortless bounds, eventually making the Atari 5200 seem like a mere San Fransisco Rush. Indeed, out of the blue came soaring the Gauntlet – the burly and enduring Nintendo Entertainment System. Along with her came yet another HardDrivin ‘ force: they called him, Mario. With hammer in hand, the mysterious plumber and his brother won my family’s heart — and when I came hurdling out of the ether, I learned to love him just as the Paperboy loves a good, healthy readership.
The Nintendo wasn’t alone, though. Riding in a glorious black ship in the NES’s wake came the strong but vulnerable Sega Master System. Its hair was groomed finely, it surrounded itself with a strong crew, and most importantly, it had a sense of style that Nintendo just couldn’t match – however, its most important role was that it was a vanguard. The Sega Master System was simply a testing of the waters. As soon as its signature characters stepped from the gangplank onto the fertile soils of Reagan’s America, an unmatchable rivalry was born.
When Sonic was born on the SMS in 1991, suddenly, our Super Mario Brothers 3 had both a competitor and a rival. It wasn’t simply Final Fantasy vs. Phantasy Star - it was the birth of something much bigger than myself. It wasn’t just grey vs. black, or price vs. price — this was Mario vs. Sonic, and I was born right into it.
I suppose that, in retrospect, fanboyism was just completely silly when scaled to all of the immensely terrible things happening in the world at the time. However, you know the drill - when you’re a little kid the world scales according to where you are. Unfortunately/fortunately, I was born into a suburban culture of gamers, and we treated it as if it were a facet of life itself. This was a time where everybody played video games , and everybody had an allegiance - it was just what kids did. Suburbia wasn’t the most exciting place to be, and we replaced that boredom with the vicarious excitement that game politics brought up. It fueled our childhood arguments, and it collected our thoughts together into a single, identifiable clique - and you know, I don’t think any of us really saw a problem with it. Nothing then seemed more natural than being loyal to a single company.
Gosh, I can still distinctively remember kids actually having physical fights and forcing other kids into isolation just because of their particular preference. We’d have arguments in class, kids would fight over Mega Man vs. Alex Kidd, Mario vs. Sonic and Robotnik vs. Bowser - just really stupid stuff. I’m pretty sure that, if it was either red or blue respectively, we’d probably have kids fighting each other from either side of the room, praising its virtues out loud. This is how it was for the first couple years of my school life, pretty consistently. We Nintendo kids had our Gameboys in tow, and the Sega kids had their (admittedly impressive) Game Gears and Nomads failing to do their backpacks justice. We’d grasp at straws for anything to insult the systems over – “Hey Game Gear! Why don’t you use sixty more batteries! Ha!” and “Hey Gameboy! Have you gone blind yet from your tiny screen?”
As with most kids, we measured one major milestone in the console war first - that was one of Pokemon. Every kid played it, and every kid played with the cards. If I could ever remember one time in which Sega was just a word forbidden, it was when Pikachu was king. Suddenly, though, it was inaugurated as a moment where videogames didn’t matter anymore. We started to grow up into middle school (grades 6-8, for you non-Americans out there), and kids disappeared into other cliques and fads.
While they were busy stealing cigarettes from their siblings and drinking stolen boxes of wine coolers, there were just a few of us that were left to fight the rest of the war. Middle school is a strange and awkward time for kids, though - instead of attempting to fit in with the girls of my time, a couple of us decided to become even more dedicated to our respective camps. I fell completely into Nintendo, abandoning my passionate (but secret) love for the Sega Genesis and dedicated myself as a Nintendo boy - I only bought and played Nintendo systems. Other friends gave up their SNESes and bought into the (respectively ill-favored) 32Xes, the Sega-CDs, the Sega Saturns and the Dreamcasts. We’d tease each other constantly, but within the tumultuous and heartbreaking world of being a 6th grader, we were all happy with the state of our own camps.
As we played our exclusives, PlayStation rolled its tanks through our world. As I moved through high school, being loyal to a company became less important. I was beginning to play PS1 and PS2 games that my brother brought home, and everything was okay. I was in happy game land, and that section of my life was filled with cream. That’s when the console war ended in a whimper - and the same thing that was so important to me growing up was just a sliding headline seated on a silent ticker tape. I remember reading about it in EGM that bitter Pennsylvanian winter of 2001 - Sega’s Dreamcast was done, and Sega would be making games for other systems now.
And just like that, Sega, the once mighty rival, was reduced to just yet another blip on the third-party radar. Nintendo won. Sonic began appearing everywhere - and only becoming successful on Nintendo systems. That went against everything I’d ever grown up to expect, and you know what? I didn’t care. I care now, with the side-by-side release of Sonic and the Secret Rings and Sonic on the 360 - on the back of its greatest enemy seems to be the only way for Sonic to really flourish. Sega’s been successful elsewhere, but apparently, only true enemies can work together.
Rumas discussed this a bit, but from my perspective, there aren’t really words to express the shock of Mario and Sonic appearing legally in their first game together. It feels appropriate, I suppose, but coming from a world where they were separated so viciously, I’ve never felt so apathetic towards such an exciting game. I’m not outraged, but I’m not approving either. Perhaps the kids these days who grew up outside of the Great Console War will care a little bit more than I do – but it still feels wrong.
It sounds so silly to put so many fond memories in a war that was about as real as the Cola Wars, but for we little kids that grew up around it, it was certainly a real thing. It’s over now, and we’ve moved on to an even greater cold war - but even as Mario and Sonic compete in the Olympic Games, I’ll remember back to the times when this wouldn’t be a sign of peace among camps: it’d be a shot of mockery across our collective bows. I’ll remember to a time when games were all that kept our little minds together in the tear-jerkingly boring world of suburbia. And most of all, I’m not going to play as Sonic, ever.
Eff Sonic.











Wow… Just… wow…
Mitch, unless I read your article incorrectly, you and I are almost the same age. I remember those days! I remember secretly loving the original Sonic the Hedgehog but hating the fact that he would never show up on my Super Nintendo. I remember being made fun of by the ‘cool’ kids for still playing a ‘babies game’ like Pokemon in 6th grade, and subsequently not caring.
Then I remember hearing about Sega’s end in the console battlefield… I was in a numb shock of sorts. Sega was the enemy I had come to love to hate, and I felt an odd mix of victory and disappointment. Now I’m able to play those Sonic games I used to hide my love for untethered, and on the very same system as I play my Mario games.
I may not share your anti-sonic sentiments, but I thank you for initiating that trip down memory lane, and the resulting feeling of nostalgia.
JonEthan - 04.03.07 12:12 am
Look at it this way, they’re still competing for first place in the olympics
Only one side will win and it’s the red side.
Edgar - 04.03.07 12:17 am
That was a great read but I gotta say I never really saw Nintendo and Sega as mortal enemies. I bought my SNES about a year before I bought my Genesis, and I always viewed them as two totally different types of consoles with their own unique libraries. Super Metroid, Contra III, Castlevania IV, FF6 vs. Gunstar Heroes, Sonic, Golden Axe, Shinobi, Strider… I will, however, say that the Sega Saturn is Sega’s most under appreciated console. Games like Panzer Dragoon Saga, Shining Force III, Radiant Silvergun, Battle Garrega, and a billion other shooters are found only on the Saturn. Treasure was almost exclusively with Sega for the longest time. I was absolutely THRILLED when they ported Ikaruga to the Gamecube. Those of us who loved vertical shooters, and couldn’t afford a Neo Geo, opted for the Saturn. What did the mighty N have to compete with the Saturn? The Virtual Boy, which I still have and love, but once again is an entirely different type of game system. I really don’t see the battle. Two different companies offering two entirely different products. I’m thrilled for Sega to stick with making games instead of consoles. If it weren’t for the 32x and the Sega CD they might have still been a contender in the hardware department.
Drake - 04.03.07 12:23 am
CUTMANS IS TEH BEST!!1 AND TEH ATARI JAGUAR PWNS DEM ALL!!1
whizkid64 - 04.03.07 12:34 am
I was one of the lucky kids who got both systems.
And love them both (just liked Nintendo a bit more)
But after Sega Cd, 32x (yes i got them both) I started to lean towards Nintendo more and more.
It was not until i saw Sega Saturn & Nights I stoped buying sega systems. No Sonic and Weird looking guy on Nights made me pass on the SS.
Now i regret not getting it, i hear it has some really great 2d games for it
now its 2007, i can’t wait for Nights 2 and I have all 3 systems and love um all. (just love Nintendo a bit more)
LeXxX - 04.03.07 12:59 am
The Mario & Sonic game, when announced, didnt make me flip out like some people have. Sonic basically has been stripped down to a B-list type of game franchise thats had a heap of bad games since sega went multi, and seeing Sonic with Mario in some Olympic marketing crap (no matter how well it’s made) is just sad to see.
NoBullet - 04.03.07 1:13 am
God I feel old
I played nes in grade school, snes in high school and N64 in college.
silkylove - 04.03.07 1:19 am
San Francisco Rush? Gauntlet? Hard Drivin’? Paperboy? Hey, what’s with all the Atari Games title references near the top?
John H. - 04.03.07 2:09 am
It never really was a battle for me. I had the genesis, and I loved that system, but I have to admit, my cousin had the Super Nintendo and whenever he came over with the system, I’d get all excited. “Yes, now I can play Super Mario World.” But don’t misunderstand, I played and absolutely loved the Sonic games, and a plethora of other quality titles for the Genesis. But I never saw Sega and Nintendo as competitors. I was young, so maybe that’s why, but you know what, I liked it that way. My focus nowadays has totally changed. I love Nintendo, but I want to see quality titles from all companies, so that way the industry that I love so much stays healthy. In some ways, it’s kind of scary the amount of impact that Nintendo alone has had. I mean, that’s all I can think about is the DS and Wii. I think more people and companies need to kind of get onboard. Realize that Wii and DS are here to stay and that people really do enjoy these systems. Anyways, great article! Keep up the great work, 4CR!!
Matt - 04.03.07 2:27 am
Good story. I share many of the same feelings, and I do have to sometimes pinch myself when I see the new Sonic titles on Nintendo consoles.
I’m fine with it though, I did actually prefer Sonic as a kid despite only owning an NES.
Jephso - 04.03.07 6:10 am
It’s true; Cut Man really is the best.
Hmm, somehow, I was oblivious to the whole console war thing back in the day. I had a SNES, and my friend had a Genesis, but we never gave each other crap. I mean, it never even occured to us. He loved Illusion of Gaia and Secret of Mana on my SNES, and I loved Phantasy Star IV and Beyond Oasis on his Genesis. I wasn’t even aware of ‘console wars’ until a few years ago, somehow.
As for Sonic, I’ve never been a big fan. The thought of Sonic games rivaling Mario games has always been bullshit to me. I played all the original Genesis games, and even back then, I didn’t think they were that great. They were good, not great - certainly not anywhere in the same league as Super Mario World and Yoshi’s Island.
I don’t really think it’s wrong for Mario and Sonic to be in a game together, though. Not that I care about this particular game, but that’s just because I’m not a fan of sports games (I’ve probably played Wii Sports less than at least 99% of Wii owners). However, if we end up seeing Sonic show up in Smash Bros. Brawl, I think he’ll be a fitting addition, though I’d personally much rather see Mega Man.
ZBEGYAH!
Juja - 04.03.07 8:22 am
I’m not sure of the average age of the readers here, but this article really brought me back. Big time.
My first experience with the NES was at a friend’s house in 1989. He had the power pad and we spent hours playing track games and Castlevania. It was a great game, albeit one that I only remember slightly.
I remember getting an NES in 1990, and along with Super Mario Bros./Duck Hunt I bought Excite Bike and was hooked. That was it. My life was games, and that was the way it was going to stay. Mario was the best thing to happen to games EVER, and new games like Mega Man just cemented that fact. It really was a golden age for games.
Then SEGA came along with the Genesis. The SMS never really made an impact where I lived in the Northeast, but the Genesis was really a huge hit. I cracked, and bought a Genesis. Sonic was an amazing game, and all I remember was how FAST everything moved. Mario could never take off like this, and he really hasn’t since.
At school, we’d bring the latest Game Pro issues to class and discuss new codes and games. Contra was still a big hit then - we’d enter the 99 lives code and play it over and over again. Then my neighbor got an SNES for Christmas. Wow! Mario looks good. The colors are good. Everything looks great. What am I going to do with my Genesis now?
So I cracked and mowed lawns for almost the entire summer to purchase an SNES and it was one of the best investments of my life. Mario, and Zelda. Again. With better animation and better color than I could ever have imagined.
Around 1993 I suffered a relapse and went back to my Genesis andn began playing newer titles like Sonic 2. Wow, this is sweet. Two characters on screen at once, blazing through loops and tunnels! Sign me up!
But then a little company called NEC grabbed me with the TG-16. I played Keith Courage and Bonk for months without boredom. Then came the CD-rom attachment. Then came Street Fighter II. Yikes, this is getting complicated!
Just like Mitch said, kids those days in suburbia had little else to do other than argue about which system was the best. Often, this was usually a matter of which game system your parents bought you - and in many cases friends would get the system they didn’t want. “A game system is a game system. What’s the difference?” was always the parents response. C’est la vie.
With the news of Mario and Sonic together in a game, it makes me laugh. Not in the sense of how crappy the game could turn out to be, but in the sense that all of our childhood rivalries are essentially destroyed. Remember the old advertisement “Sega Does What Nintendon’t”? That pretty much states how nasty things were getting at the time. I guess old wounds DO heal.
I’ll admit, I was never a out and out fanboy of any system. I never stuck to just one machine in my childhood. I was more the dirty flirt who played around with everyone, never really feeling satisfied with just one experience.
That being said, let’s bring Mario, Sonic, and Bonk together for a real trip back to the 90s. That would be MY ultimate game.
Tim - 04.03.07 8:53 am
I was in 5th grade when the shat hit the fan in ‘91. I remember the great debated that waged on…do we get our brother (and essentially ourselves) a Sega Genesis or a Super Nintendo? I wasn’t exposed to the conflict until this generation. So we weighed the options…Sega had Sonic, which was mad fun. SNES had Mario…which we’ve played over and over again. Eventually, we ended up with the SNES…why? Zelda and a little third-party title called Street Fighter II. And we never looked back
Lol, the debate always raged on whenever we’d go to a Genesis household. “Our MK has blood!” “Oh yeah? Ours looks better!” “We have Sonic!” “We have six buttons built in to play SFII!”
Seriously, playing SFII on the original Genesis controller was pure sin…
DCSimian - 04.03.07 9:35 am
The Atari Lynx beat all handhelds hands down for YEARS until the arrival of Nintendo DS and PSP.
Blee Blee Bloo Bloo - 04.03.07 10:06 am
silkylove: with ya. got my NES in 1st grade.
sean but not heard - 04.03.07 10:14 am
Sure, the Sonic games were fun, but it’s not fair to compare then to the likes of Super Mario Bros. 3. The games are in their own separate leagues.
Lemond - 04.03.07 11:30 am
It was in teh 3rd grade just me a pillow and 3 things of chocalte pudding
whizkid64 - 04.03.07 12:37 pm
Let’s put it like this: (NOTE- THIS IS MY OPINION!)
Super Mario Bros. > Sonic the Hedgehog
Super Mario Bros. 2 (US) Sonic Adventure
Super Mario 64 Sonic Heroes (BY A LONGSHOT!)
Super Mario Galaxy = Sonic and the Secret Rings? Maybe. We’ll find out later about that one…
Crimson Warrior - 04.03.07 2:40 pm
Whoopsie. Forgot that you can use HTML in comments. Half the brackets are gone.
So, an edit of the above:
Super Mario Bros. 2 (US) is worse than Sonic the Hedgehog 2
Super Mario Bros. 3 is worse than Sonic the Hedgehog 3 and Knuckles
Super Mario 64 is better than Sonic Adventure
Super Mario 64 is worse than Sonic Adventure 2
Super Mario Sunshine is better than Sonic Heroes (BY A LONGSHOT!)
That better guys? Sorry about that.
Crimson Warrior - 04.03.07 2:43 pm
OK, final comment, when I read the first few words I thought I was reading something out of a Sonic the Hedgehog comic from 1998. They had their own “Great War” before Sonic was born. It was a very good explaination of how Humans and Furries became separated. Bah, whatever. Read everyone else’s comments now…
Crimson Warrior - 04.03.07 2:45 pm
I was a Sega girl.
God, I remember the fervent hatred of Mario, and the guilt of my secret affair with Zelda. I even put my SNES and my Genesis on opposite sides of the cabinet so they would not have to see each other.
Of course, all of us Sega fankids in our Nintendo antipathy failed to realize what we know now– alas, it was Sony who destroyed our Dreamcast, not Nintendo. Maybe I did know that back then, but wanted to play Final Fantasy VII so bad I ignored the facts.
Leigh - 04.03.07 4:08 pm
Mitch, you dissapoint me. How can you hate Sonic? He is a huge cultural icon, he has starred in some great games (SatSR, Rush are the most recent) and now he’s helping Nintendo. You sicken me.
Gojiguy - 04.03.07 5:56 pm
When I first started getting into gaming, I didn’t think anyone else shared my secret hobby, besides my brother. We grew up on NES- played the thing ’till it died, then got a Saturn from our grandparents and fell in love with Virtua Fighter, Virtua Cop, Panzer Dragoon (which is apparently worth some moolah now-a-days, wish I could find it), and an odd 2-player simulatneous side scrolling platformer apparently no one else has ever even heard of; Astal.
Then we moved to the fringes of town, a suburb no less, and I fell in with the local group of Nintendo fanboys, my brother bought an N64, I bought LoZ:OoT, and after that life-changing experience became a dedicated, confirmed gamer for life.
I missed the console war, because I never found gamer friends to hang with (being a girl it was super-hard, they never believed me
) until the war was already pretty much over.
siempre - 04.03.07 6:04 pm
nintendo is 4 kiddys sonic cud kick the crap out of stupid fat mario so THERE.
yeah,as much as i enjoyed playing on my friends’s SNES, i was a viciously sega child. After years of begging, my first console was a megadrive- though my mother asked me if i wanted a SNES instead at one point, i dont know if she had a secret mario habit or if the SNES was cheaper back then, but i wasnt having any of it, all the cool kids had sega and i wanted me a damn sega.
She tried to pull the same thing on me when i asked for my ps2 all those years ago too actually. only suggesting i get a dreamcastm which were criminally cheap then with absolutley fantastic bundle deals. I kinda wish i’d stayed so vehemently sega, because when i did eventually get round to buying a dreamcast years later i fell head over heels in love with it
ALH - 04.03.07 6:52 pm
Siempre: haha, you would never have believed how we treated girls who played games. Then again, that was in our prime “girls have cooties” days as well.
Mitch - 04.03.07 7:24 pm
Anyone else notice that red and blue are rival gang colors?
Mrevilbobguy - 04.04.07 3:13 am
I love Sonic, but have loads of Nintendo consoles…and am a playstation girl…
Meh…
Purry - 04.04.07 11:43 am
I really enjoyed reading this..it dredged up so many fond memories.
As a girl gamer, it was never so much a console war as a battle of the sexes. I was never so much of one side or the other, because the boys and my folks wouldn’t allow it. Girls were supposed to play with the dolls they kept pushing on me, or toy with the makeup that never quite managed to entertain my fancy.
I was always the sideliner to my brothers’ gaming obsession, even though my want to play was as great as thiers. Whenever they’d go to the bathroom, I’d grab the controller. I’d always rush to eat dinner so I could get back to playing first. I never had a console of my own until I saved up and bought a SNES on release day, with Super Mario World. Don’t get my wrong, I HAVE played all the classics. However, my precarious position let me play both sides of the no man’s land, and I got to enjoy the entire array of classics.
Suffice to say that I never got partically attached to either side just because I was shunned by both. Well, that was until FF7 arrived, and I moved into the Sony encampment as if I had always belonged.
The male gamers, for the most part, underestimate the girl players. Maybe thier pride won’t let them believe that a female can master the ultimate code for Street Fighter, or annihilate them at Need for Speed. But we’re out there, and growing in force. And you know why?
Because we were told “No.”, and nothing in heaven and earth makes a woman want to do something more than when she’s told she can’t.
Btw, Nintendo all the way.
Jangalian - 04.05.07 3:40 pm
….holy….shit. ROFL. Dude, I seriously wish I had grown up in your neighboorhood. Real life console wars hahaha. So awesome man. I guess I wasn’t really a fanboy at all compared to you back in your day.
daeyeth - 04.05.07 3:48 pm
holy crackerjacks batman! is mitch a girl? maybe i just missed that somewhere…idk…also i couldnt quite figure out how old you were because you said you were born in the early 90’s (??? i think) but then said something about reagan’s america…so uh wtf? im thinking i read it wrong or there was a typo about the 90’s or something…anyone know?
ohemgeez - 04.08.07 11:33 pm
I have no experience with this. I and my friends just felt lucky to get ahold of abandoned yardsale NES and SNESs and games.
Baramos - 04.10.07 12:17 pm
I really love this game. I think it would be a good match between Sonic & Mario. Sega & Nintendo should team up for all their videogames.
Matt - 04.12.07 8:06 pm
I really love this game. I think it would be a good match between Sonic & Mario. Sega & Nintendo should team up for all their videogames.
P.S… Sorry, wrong name from above. My name is Josh. My first time commenting. I’m only 8 and I love videogames. Their kickass.
Josh - 04.12.07 8:07 pm